Water hardness in Shirley, NY

Water in Shirley is soft, with a median of 42 mg/L (2.5 grains per gallon) across 44 monitoring sites within 10 miles.

45% softer than the New York median (77 mg/L) 144th hardest of 193 New York towns Population 27,854 (2010)
42mg/L
2.5 grains per gallon
Soft

Shirley tap water at a glance

Choosing a filter? Whole-house vs under-sink · Reverse osmosis · Hot or cold tap water?

What 42 mg/L means at home

  • Water softener: A water softener is generally not needed. Soft water rarely causes scale.
  • Dishwasher: set the water hardness to about 2.5 gpg (2.4 °dH), which is the lowest hardness setting (or softener off).
  • Kettles and coffee makers: descaling every 3–6 months is usually enough.
  • Laundry and soap: soap lathers easily and detergent goes further.
  • Water heater: routine flushing every 2–3 years is typically fine.

Where the number comes from

Monitoring sites44
Lab samples236
Sample years2000–2023
Middle 50% of sites19–57 mg/L
Groundwater (wells, springs)44 mg/L · 32 sites
Surface water (rivers, lakes)26 mg/L · 12 sites

Measured hardness of local source water (mg/L as calcium carbonate) from Water Quality Portal (USGS, EPA and state agencies). Utilities that soften or blend water may deliver different numbers, so check your utility's Consumer Confidence Report for exact tap values. Methodology · On a private well? How to test it

Water softener and dishwasher calculator for Shirley

Prefilled with Shirley's measured local hardness of 42 mg/L (2.5 gpg). If your water bill or utility report gives a different number, enter it instead.

Softener capacity needed (at least)–
Dishwasher setting–set your dishwasher's water hardness to this
Sodium added by softening–

Softener sizes assume the EPA average of 82 gallons per person per day; sodium uses about 8 mg/L added per grain removed (University of Nebraska–Lincoln). More: do you need a softener? · softener salt and sodium · hardness converter

PFAS in Shirley tap water

Shirley is served by more than one water system. These systems supply ZIP codes in Shirley and were tested for PFAS ("forever chemicals") in EPA's nationwide UCMR 5 study. Check your water bill to see which one is yours.

Water systems serving Shirley

Water systemPFAS detectedHighest PFOA / PFOSTested
Suffolk County Water Authority
serves over 10,000 people
PFHxA, PFPeA, 6:2 FTS +7 more 6.5 / 17.4 ppt Jan 2023 – Sep 2025

What these PFAS levels mean → Which water filters remove PFAS →

Highest single sample in parts per trillion (ppt). Limits apply to yearly averages from 2029, so one high sample is not a violation. *Limit proposed for withdrawal in 2026. ND = not detected. PFAS results for every state · Source: EPA UCMR 5 · Methodology

Lead pipes in Shirley

Shirley is served by more than one water system. Their service line inventories, as reported to EPA:

Water systems serving Shirley

Water systemService linesTotal
Suffolk County Water Authority11 lead · 0 galvanized · 54 unknown396,459

How to tell if your home has a lead pipe → Lead pipes in every state →

As reported to EPA (first quarter of 2026). Unknown lines may or may not contain lead; numbers change as utilities inspect lines. Sources: EPA service line inventory · EPA Lead and Copper Rule Improvements · Methodology

Shirley drinking water violations

Shirley is served by more than one water system. Health-based violations recorded by EPA since 2016:

Water systems serving Shirley

Water systemHealth-based violationsMonitoring/reporting
Suffolk County Water Authority12

Violations since January 2016, EPA records (2026Q3). A violation is not the same as illness; your utility's annual water quality report explains each one. Violations in every state · Source: EPA ECHO / SDWIS · Methodology

Monitoring sites closest to Shirley

SiteTypeDistanceMedianSamplesYears
CARMANS RIVER AT SOUTHHAVEN NY
USGS New York Water Science Center
Stream 0.8 mi41 mg/L212018–2023
S 2
USGS New York Water Science Center
Well 1.6 mi23 mg/L12002
S 3
USGS New York Water Science Center
Well 1.6 mi49 mg/L12002
BEAVERDAM CREEK IN BROOKHAVEN
NYS Dept. of EnCon, Division of Water
River/Stream 2.6 mi55 mg/L102004
CARMANS RIVER IN YAPHANK
NYS Dept. of EnCon, Division of Water
River/Stream 2.9 mi36 mg/L102004
CARMANS RIVER AT YAPHANK NY
USGS New York Water Science Center
Stream 3 mi45 mg/L292014–2022

Water hardness in towns near Shirley

TownDistanceMedianClass
Mastic2 mi 44 mg/LSoft
Mastic Beach3 mi 44 mg/LSoft
North Bellport4 mi 44 mg/LSoft
East Patchogue6 mi 45 mg/LSoft
Medford6 mi 44 mg/LSoft
Manorville7 mi 28 mg/LSoft
Ridge8 mi 33 mg/LSoft
Patchogue8 mi 46 mg/LSoft
Middle Island8 mi 36 mg/LSoft
Holtsville9 mi 45 mg/LSoft

Suffolk County

Shirley is in Suffolk County, where the median is 36 mg/L (soft) across 144 sites.

See all of Suffolk County →

New York

The statewide median is 77 mg/L (moderately hard) from 2,847 sites.

New York hardness map →

Hardness scale

Soft0–60 mg/L0–3.5 gpg
Moderately hard61–120 mg/L3.5–7 gpg
Hard121–180 mg/L7–10.5 gpg
Very hardover 180 mg/Lover 10.5 gpg

What to read next