Do you need a water softener?

Updated November 20, 2026 · Based on EPA and other public sources listed below · How we make our content

Short answer: you probably don't need a softener if your water is under about 7 grains per gallon (120 mg/L). Above that, scale on fixtures, appliances and water heaters becomes noticeable, and above 10.5 gpg (180 mg/L) softeners are common. Check your town's hardness first, then size the softener with the calculator below.

Step 1: find your water hardness

Look up your town on the water hardness map, read your utility's annual Consumer Confidence Report, or test a private well. Hardness is reported in milligrams per liter (mg/L) or grains per gallon (gpg); 1 gpg = 17.1 mg/L. Cities that publish their tap water hardness:

CityHardnessClassSoftener?
New York, NY 31 mg/L · 1.8 gpg Soft Not needed
Los Angeles, CA 170 mg/L · 9.9 gpg Hard Optional, common
Chicago, IL 135 mg/L · 7.9 gpg Hard Optional, common
Phoenix, AZ 218 mg/L · 12.7 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Philadelphia, PA 125 mg/L · 7.3 gpg Hard Optional, common
San Antonio, TX 300 mg/L · 17.5 gpg Very hard Commonly used
San Diego, CA 276 mg/L · 16.1 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Dallas, TX 138 mg/L · 8.1 gpg Hard Optional, common
Jacksonville, FL 246 mg/L · 14.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Austin, TX 93 mg/L · 5.4 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Fort Worth, TX 128 mg/L · 7.5 gpg Hard Optional, common
Columbus, OH 115 mg/L · 6.7 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Charlotte, NC 39 mg/L · 2.3 gpg Soft Not needed
Indianapolis, IN 292 mg/L · 17.1 gpg Very hard Commonly used
San Francisco, CA 8 mg/L · 0.5 gpg Soft Not needed
Seattle, WA 28 mg/L · 1.6 gpg Soft Not needed
Denver, CO 105 mg/L · 6.1 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Las Vegas, NV 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Boston, MA 16 mg/L · 0.9 gpg Soft Not needed
Detroit, MI 116 mg/L · 6.8 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Louisville/Jefferson County metro government, KY 135 mg/L · 7.9 gpg Hard Optional, common
Milwaukee, WI 138 mg/L · 8.1 gpg Hard Optional, common
Kansas City, MO 100 mg/L · 5.8 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Aurora, CO 136 mg/L · 7.9 gpg Hard Optional, common
New Orleans, LA 101 mg/L · 5.9 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Cleveland, OH 117 mg/L · 6.8 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Henderson, NV 304 mg/L · 17.8 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Lubbock, TX 192 mg/L · 11.2 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Paradise, NV 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Sioux Falls, SD 250 mg/L · 14.6 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Amarillo, TX 238 mg/L · 13.9 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Oxnard, CA 319 mg/L · 18.6 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Sunrise Manor, NV 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Spring Valley, NV 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Corona, CA 146 mg/L · 8.5 gpg Hard Optional, common
Syracuse, NY 127 mg/L · 7.4 gpg Hard Optional, common
Metairie, LA 78 mg/L · 4.6 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Warren, MI 105 mg/L · 6.1 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
West Valley City, UT 176 mg/L · 10.3 gpg Hard Optional, common
Simi Valley, CA 140 mg/L · 8.2 gpg Hard Optional, common
Thousand Oaks, CA 140 mg/L · 8.2 gpg Hard Optional, common
Vallejo, CA 153 mg/L · 8.9 gpg Hard Optional, common
Concord, CA 74 mg/L · 4.3 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Independence, MO 123 mg/L · 7.2 gpg Hard Optional, common
West Jordan, UT 183 mg/L · 10.7 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Richmond, CA 68 mg/L · 4 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Carlsbad, CA 230 mg/L · 13.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Santa Maria, CA 315 mg/L · 18.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Enterprise, NV 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Centennial, CO 105 mg/L · 6.1 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Dearborn, MI 102 mg/L · 6 gpg Moderately hard Usually not needed
Yuma, AZ 345 mg/L · 20.2 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Whitney, NV 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used
Winchester, NV 280 mg/L · 16.4 gpg Very hard Commonly used

Tap water hardness as published by each city's water utility. For any other town, look it up on the map.

Step 2: decide by hardness

HardnessWhat you'll noticeSoftener
Soft: under 3.5 gpg (60 mg/L)Soap lathers easily, little or no scaleNot needed
Moderately hard: 3.5–7 gpgLight spots on glass and fixturesUsually not needed
Hard: 7–10.5 gpgScale in kettles and showerheads, spotting, more detergentOptional; many homes choose one
Very hard: over 10.5 gpg (180 mg/L)Heavy scale, water heater sediment, stiff laundryCommonly used

Hard water is not a health risk. The case for a softener is about scale, cleaning and appliance upkeep (see hard water and your water heater), weighed against salt, water use and added sodium.

Step 3: size the softener

Softeners are rated by how many grains of hardness they remove between regenerations. Work out how many grains your household uses per day, multiply by the number of days you want between regenerations, and choose a softener rated above that at the salt setting you plan to use.

Grains per day = people × gallons per person per day × hardness (gpg)

EPA puts average indoor use at about 82 gallons per person per day; your actual use may be lower or higher.

Water softener size calculator

If your water also contains iron or manganese, ask the manufacturer how to adjust the size, since they use up softening capacity. Ratings depend on the salt setting, so compare softeners at the same salt dose.

Trade-offs to know before you buy

  • Sodium: softening adds about 8 mg/L of sodium per gpg removed. Many homes keep an unsoftened cold tap in the kitchen for drinking and cooking. Calculate the sodium in your softened water.
  • Salt: you'll refill the brine tank with salt. Potassium chloride can replace sodium chloride but costs more and can need more per regeneration. Some California communities restrict salt-based softeners: see salt-free vs salt-based softeners.
  • Water and septic: each regeneration uses about 50 gallons that go down the drain.
  • Regeneration control: demand-initiated (metered) models regenerate only when needed and usually use less salt and water than timer models.
  • Certification: look for NSF/ANSI 44 or the WQA Gold Seal on the softener.
  • A softener is not a filter: it doesn't remove PFAS, lead or bacteria. See filters that remove PFAS.

Thinking of a softener for skin problems? See what research found about hard water and eczema.

Need a measurement first? See how to test your water hardness.

Frequently asked questions

At what hardness do you need a water softener?

There is no legal or health threshold: hard water is not a health risk. Most households start to notice scale and spotting once water is hard (over about 7 grains per gallon, 120 mg/L), and softeners are common in very hard water areas (over 10.5 gpg, 180 mg/L).

How much sodium does a water softener add?

About 8 mg of sodium per liter for each grain per gallon of hardness removed, according to the University of Nebraska–Lincoln. Water that starts at 10 gpg ends up with about 80 mg/L of sodium. People on low-sodium diets should ask their doctor, or keep an unsoftened cold tap for drinking.

How much water does a softener use?

Each regeneration uses roughly 50 gallons of water, according to the University of Nebraska–Lincoln. Demand-initiated (metered) softeners regenerate only when needed and generally use less salt and water than timer models.

Can I use softened water on plants?

It isn't recommended for repeated watering of plants, lawns or gardens, because of the sodium. Many homes plumb outdoor taps to bypass the softener.

Is a softener OK with a septic system?

Regeneration water goes down the drain, which adds load to a septic system. Check with your septic professional; demand-initiated models reduce how often it happens.

Sources

Related guides